In general, when people talk about the difference between literary fiction and genre fiction, theyre talking about the difference between art and entertainment. The author spends pages showing who the characters are, what drives and moves them, what they want, why what they want is. The dichotomy between genre and literary fiction, he or she wrote, relies on concepts of literary value that few people share. The other possible genre for my book is historical fiction, which is a novel set in a particular historical time, usually with fictional characters as the drivers of the plot. Krystal argues that literary fiction is better than genre fiction for a number of reasons. Its important to know the difference between fiction and nonfiction so that you can select the right books for different kinds of assignments. There are three genre novels up for the giller prize readers choice. Literary fiction is usually written to create a work of art that extends the art of literature in a new way. Look at books that have many qualities similar to your own work and see how those. What are the main differences between literary fiction and. In general, fiction refers to plot, settings, and characters created from the imagination, while nonfiction refers to factual stories focused on actual events and people. The main difference between these types of fiction is in their mass appeal and accessibility. What is the difference between literary fiction, fiction.
The essays are thoughtprovoking and murky the waters not just a little bit. Traditional differences between genre and literary fiction. When it comes to literary fiction it is all about the proses, beauty and how thought provoking a book can be. Its usually considered the longest form of literary prose. In publishing, literary fiction novels are regarded as having more literary merit than most commercial or genre fiction. The traditional differences between genre and literary fiction are outlined in the table below. Interpretive fiction, literary fiction, high art, etc. Many genre books have elements of literary fiction and vice versa and there is increasingly a third category of crossover fiction that will be discussed below. Genre fiction and literary fiction is there a difference.
The common names for these two divergent types of fiction are literary fiction and popular or genre fiction. The distinction between literary fiction and genre fiction is neither contemporary nor ageless. Fiction, of course, is a work that is imagined from the mind, a different. The writer of a literary novel can tackle any subject, any themethough these arent necessarily the most important part of the story. Literary is important, fancy, thinky, whatever any of that means. We feel differently though which shows the nature of this ongoing discussion. Books in the literary fiction genre tend to be more sophisticated than books that are simply labeled as commercial, mainstream, or general fiction. Fiction refers to a story containing imaginary or made up events.
What is the difference between commercial and literary. For writers and readers alike, its sometimes hard to tell the difference between fiction and nonfiction. Literary fiction can cover the same topic but executed a little differently. The most famous genres are science fiction, fable, horror, western, mystery, romance, chick lit.
Literary fiction, on the other hand, is a bit trickier to define. Also, fiction can refer to things outside of writing. Its the product of modernism, and it bears the stamp of a unique time in literary history. This contrasts with nonfiction, factbased work including essays, memoirs, biographies, histories, journalism, and other works that are factual in scope.
Neal stephenson has suggested that, while any definition will be simplistic, there is today a general cultural difference between literary and genre fiction. The term is principally used to distinguish serious fiction which is a work that claims to hold literary merit, in comparison from genre fiction and popular fiction. The inference here is that the dichotomy between genre fiction and literary fiction is a false one. Literature vs genre is a battle where both sides lose books the. However, the difference between these two genres is sometimes blurred, as the two often intersect. Their preference results in reading increasingly more challenging books, those that demand attention to the aesthetic quality of writing e. That said, there are some general statements that can be said about literary and genre fiction that help differentiate them.
All these books were identified by their publishers as eligible literary fiction. On his facebook page, david gerrold recently posted a link to an article on how mainstream readers wont read genre fiction as closely as they read mainstream or literary fiction the reaction to the article seems to be mostly misguided, thinking it accuses science fiction as. On the one hand, literary authors are frequently supported by patronage, with employment at a university or a similar institution, and with the continuation of such positions determined not by book sales but by critical. Heres my delineation of the difference between commercial and literary fiction. Most people are still unaware of the differences between fiction and nonfiction. Literary fiction tends to be very symbolic, thick, poetic, and focus more on themes, the actual. What is the difference between genre fiction and literary fiction. Frantz, associate professor of english at fayetteville state university in north carolina, is president of the international association for the study of popular romance and the author of articles on jane austen, j. The difference between fiction and nonfiction youtube. In general, it emphasizes meaning over entertainment.
Literary fiction definition complete list of book genres. Its true that fiction can be defined as literature invented by the imagination. Fiction vs literary fiction the difference between fiction and literary fiction is that literary fiction focuses upon style and depth, and is character driven, whereas genre fiction is plot driven, has a broader viewpoint, and focuses more upon imaginary details. Genre fiction, author steven petite echoed similar sentiments, stating that, literary fiction is comprised of the heart and soul of a writers being, and is experienced as an emotional journey through the symphony of words, leading to a stronger grasp of the. Literary fiction appeals to a smaller audience, compared to fiction which has a broader audience. The bestselling authors of the commercially viable femaleoriented genre, including jennifer weiner, have vociferously jumped into. Genres are fluid, and many books tow the line between them. Answers to writing questions genre gotham writers workshop. In commercial fiction the plot tends to happen above the surface and in literary fiction the plot tends to happen beneath the surface, and in literary fiction the prose has a unique, distinctive. Generally, genre fiction tends to place value on entertainment and, as a result, it tends to be more popular with mass audiences. Genres are checklists, scaffolding around which the author constructs their narrative. Ward, suzanne brockmann, and contemporary popular romance fiction. Except we can all think of examples of bad literary fiction and we can all think of examples of popular novels that are just as experimental and thoughtchewy as literary fiction. How genre fiction became more important than literary fiction.
Difference between fiction and literature difference between. Fiction means all elements of the storytelling are imagined. Marks authors have gotten sixfigure book deals, been on the nyt bestseller list, and published with houses such as random. While everything could be classified within its own genre, this book defines genre fiction as something of a pejorative. Like mainstream novels, literary novels arent confined to a specific genre. Margaret mitchells gone with the wind and ken folletts pillars of the earth are just two of the many examples of this genre. Genre tales are often very entertaining and well told but are deemed less important because they havent pushed literature to a new experience. The term fiction indicates written work that is invented by the imagination, such as novels, short stories, plays, and poems. Literary fiction and genre fiction, whats the difference. Others put the dividing line at action, with commercial fiction focusing more on plot and literary fiction emphasizing character. But the general impression is true literary novels take time to delve into character. In the course of his discussion, beha tries to make a distinction between genre fictionscifi, mystery, romance, fantasy, etc.
Fiction is usually expressed in the following types of literary narrative works like novels and short stories among others. Genre fiction uses known ways to write literature and doesnt invent something new. Movies and plays, would be considered works of fiction. While its easy to define romance, scififantasy, and other genres, it can be harder to pinpoint what exactly literature is, especially in contrast to popular, mainstream, commercial, or just plain fiction fiction.
Le guin are having a highly oldfashioned debate about the distinction between literary and genre fiction. My fiction writing book makes the distinction between literary fiction your interpretive and genre fiction analogous to your escapist fiction. Answers to writing questions career gotham writers. Whats the difference between literary fiction and genre. Because literary critics mostly care about the writing. The most obvious difference between original fiction and fanfiction is that one is fan fiction.
Mark now helps authors of all genres fiction, nonfiction, and childrens books get top literary agents, publishers, and book deals through his company literary agent undercover and the bestselling author. Difference between literary fiction and genre fiction. What is the difference between fiction and nonfiction. Popular or genre fiction is popcorn, fluff, unimportant, bubblegum, unintellectual and whatnot. Conventional wisdom says genre novels are concerned with plot, literary novels with character we, of course, know that both character and plot are central to entertaining fiction. The criteria is graded think of it as a spectrum so that a book or movie can have elements of both literary fiction and also elements of genre fiction at the same time. Its like comparing an esoteric independent theatre release to a summer blockbuster with a character licensing deal. Popular or genre fiction makes a beeline from the opening paragraph to the final scene. Examples of literary fiction authors include barbara kingsolver, john lecarre, and toni morrison.
But heres the thing, i think the musical arts are more evolved than the literary arts. Mark malatesta is a former literary agent turned author coach. Literature vs genre is a battle where both sides lose literary fiction is an artificial luxury brand but it doesnt sell. According to this nifty and educational infographic from hiptype via galleycat, the topgrossing type of fiction is literature. What this book does is talk about key points of fiction, drama, nonfiction. Well theres a pretty key distinction between the two. For both readers and writers, this longstanding debate has created a divide in. The former includes many subcategories such as mysterythriller, horror, romance, western, fantasy, science fiction, etc.
Shorter works of fiction would be a novella or a short story. An argument can be made that there are two types of fiction when it comes to novels. Some publishers embrace certain genres, while others dont. Genre fiction is more plot driven than character driven. Elana rabinovitch, the giller prizes director, has said in an interview that the gillers focus is on. Literary fiction is an artificial luxury brand but it doesnt sell. Ss rebukes when the latest round of the literary versus genre fiction wars broke out recently. The difference between popular fiction and literary fiction is subtle but unmistakable. Some chalk it up to language, categorizing artful and stylistic use as literary. There is no clear distinction between literary and commercial fiction. Fictional works encompass all forms of writing, including novels, short stories, poems and plays, as well as genres, such as science fiction, romance, mystery, fantasy and crime. It is only literatures sub branch that serves as a writing genre rather than a collective term for a group of written or spoken works as in the case of literature as a whole.
On literary fiction, and literary snobbery the literary. What is the principal difference between literary fiction. You know, aretha franklin, marvin gaye and modern singers like adele. For popular examples of genre fiction, consult the book racks in airports and grocery stores.
Literary fiction readers typically seek books as means of intellectual and aesthetic development. The latter is more difficult to classify or break apart into subcategories. While the other nominated books are what, nowadays, we call literary fiction, station eleven is set in a familiar genre universe, in. Literary fiction is a term that has come into common usage in the early 1960s. Like mozart and beethoven and genre fiction is like the musical genres, like the blues, soul, rock, pop. Others put the dividing line at action within the narrative, with commercial fiction focusing more on plot and literary fiction emphasizing character. I was hoping that this book would list types of literary genres. I disagree with that, so i dismissed the comment out of hand. Spoken works such as the epic poems of homer and medieval poets handed down by word of mouth, when writing them down. Ishiguro started it, in an interview with the new york times about his latest novel the buried giant.
Genres are typically understood as collections of structural elements. Literature vs genre is a battle where both sides lose. So nobody benefits by fencing it off from more popular writing. In an article featured in the huffington post, entitled literary fiction vs. In this video, we discuss these two book genres and look at a few examples. Literary fiction is the form that tends to wander in the telling of a story as the author explores the emotions and motives of a character. In literary fiction, careful use of language, style, and technique are often as. Genre fiction is fiction that falls into set genres or types of reports. A better way to think about the genre debate the new yorker.
105 455 43 1546 352 174 761 1061 678 739 1001 1022 1278 789 1162 116 662 1496 1274 1207 227 180 1484 1166 1162 960 975 1401 984 650 574 481 733 758 1400 1129 1161 1473 1187 148 782 1383